• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
GuideYouBest

GuideYouBest

Best Product Reviews

  • Kitchenware
    • Cooking
    • Bakeware
    • Coffee
  • Tips

11 Best Carbon Steel Pans for Browning & Searing in 2022

March 1, 2022 by Medha

Best Carbon Steel Pans Reviewed

Table of Contents

  • 11 Best Carbon-Steel Skillets You Can Trust
  • How to choose the best carbon steel skillet?
  • Frequently Asked Questions About Carbon Steel Skillets

Whether you are looking to buy a single cookware item or revamp your kitchen, it’s always a good idea to know what items deserve a space in your house. There is a lot of hearsay about Carbon steel pans and cast-iron items in the market.

While both are excellent choices and getting them home has its perks, they each have their respective share pros and cons too. If you want to buy a best carbon steel pan or are even remotely interested to know why you should be considering them over other pans, then read along to make an informative decision.

Top 10 Highly Reviewed Carbon Steel Skillets

Mauviel M’Steel Black Steel Pan

De Buyer Mineral B Carbon-Steel Pan

Matfer Bourgeat Blacksteel Pan

De Buyer Chef Carbon-Steel Pan

Craft Wok Traditional Handle Skillet

Souped Up Recipes Wok Pan

Yosukata Pre-Seasoned Steel Wok

Lodge Seasoned Carbon-Steel Skillet

KYTD Carbon-Steel Wok Pan

BK Nature Carbon Frying Pan

11 Best Carbon-Steel Skillets You Can Trust

1. De Buyer Mineral B Carbon Steel Pan

Best De Buyer mineral B Carbon Steel Pan Review
Buy from Amazon

It is no secret that De Buyer coats its pans with beeswax to protect them from oxidation. Interestingly, this also acts as a seasoning for their carbon steel pans.

Every professional out there has a soft corner for these pans because of their durability and ease of cooking. Not only are these the best carbon steel frying pans in the market they also retain the minerals and vitamins in the food and are toxic-free in nature. The handles are ergonomically designed and placed on both sides for ease of maneuvering.

Specifications:

  • Size: 12.6 inch
  • Item weight: 5.79
  • pounds

Pros:

  • Lighter than a cast iron pan.
  • Heats up quickly and evenly.
  • Convenient to clean and use.

Cons:

  • Slightly high maintenance.
  • Deglazing is required periodically.
Check Latest price on Amazon

2.Lodge Seasoned Carbon-Steel Skillet

Lodge Seasoned Carbon-Steel Skillet
Buy from Amazon

Heavy-duty steel skillets are preferred by professionals because of their durability and excellent heat retention capabilities. Well, a seasoned carbon-steel skillet is a multipurpose tool. It can be used for braising, searing, baking, frying and so much more. If you are looking to invest in a single skillet then this one is the best carbon steel fry pan in our opinion! The handle is elevated at an angle to provide the ultimate cooking experience.

Specifications:

  • Size: 12 inch
  • Item weight: 4.1 pounds

Pros:

  • Perfect for indoors and outdoors alike.
  • Even Heating.
  • Good for professional and residential cooking.

Cons:

  • Has a grainy surface.
  • Difficult to clean.
Check Latest price on Amazon

3.Craft Wok Traditional Handle Skillet

Best Craft Wok Traditional Handle Skillet Reviewed
Buy from Amazon

When it comes to food, traditional methods of cooking are trendy and also liked by many. This traditional Craft Wok pan is hand-beaten using traditional techniques by Chinese professionals! The wooden handle gives you the necessary grip required to maneuver a heavy pan such as this whilst also ensuring the excellent flavour of the food. Once the pan is seasoned, you can go ahead and cook your favourite dishes with ease.

Specifications:

  • Size: 14 inch
  • Item weight: 4.6 pounds

Pros:

  • Recommended by professionals.
  • Sturdy in nature.
  • Hand-hammered to ensure perfection.

Cons:

  • Quite heavy.
  • Difficult to maintain.
  • May potentially rust if not well-maintained.
Check Latest price on Amazon

4.Matfer Bourgeat Blacksteel Pan

Best Matfer Bourgeat Blacksteel Pan Reviewed
Buy from Amazon

If you are looking for a skillet that is a notch higher compared to the rest of the lot, then this black steel pan is the right way to go. It is highly durable and compatible with all kinds of cooking. The black carbon coating material is toxic-free and ensures even heating throughout the pan. The handle is welded directly onto the pan to increase its strength and promote ease of cooking.

Specifications:

  • Size: 11.88 inch
  • Item weight: 4.11 pounds

Pros:

  • Durable and long-lasting.
  • Suitable for all kinds of meat.
  • Extra black carbon coating.

Cons:

  • Quite heavy.
  • Difficult to maintain..
Check Latest price on Amazon

5. Souped Up Recipes Carbon Steel Electric Wok Pan

Best Souped Up Recipes Carbon Steel Electric Wok Pan Reviewed
Buy from Amazon

Every once in a while you come across utensils that are no less than gems and it is your duty to hold on to them no matter what, this carbon steel wok pan is one such beauty! Unlike other wok pans, this has a flat bottom and can be easily used on all kinds of kitchen tops, be it electric or gas. The printed hammered texture is absolutely gorgeous and along with the steel spatula and a wooden lid, this carbon steel pan is a one-stop solution for all your Asian cooking. The steel handle comes with a loop, so storage is not going to be a problem at all!

Specifications:

  • Size: 12.5 inch
  • Item weight: 5.37 pounds

Pros:

  • Easy to clean and non-stick.
  • Suitable for large families.

Cons:

  • Required periodic seasoning.
  • Heavy-weighted.
Check Latest price on Amazon

6.Mauviel M’Steel Black Steel Pan

Best Mauviel M’Steel Black Steel Pan Reviewed
Buy from Amazon

French cuisines are devoured all around the world. One reason for their excellent taste and flavour is the French cookware. These utensils get better and better with age and can be passed down as family heirlooms. After the ritualistic seasoning of carbon steel pans, they can be used for all kinds of cooking, from searing to frying and stirring. The carbon steel pan comes pre-seasoned with beeswax to protect it from rusting and the iron handle is sturdy and durable. Lastly, the skillet is a great conductor of heat, the black steel ensures that heat spreads evenly throughout the pan and also gives it a nonstick coating.


Specifications:

  • Size: 11 inch
  • Item weight: 1 pound

Pros:

  • Easy to clean and non-stick.
  • Light-weight and durable

Cons:

  • May warp if not maintained well.
  • Requires periodic seasoning.
Check Latest price on Amazon

7. Yosukata Pre-Seasoned Black Steel Wok

Best Yosukata Pre-Seasoned Black Steel Wok Reviewed
Buy from Amazon

Talking about pre-seasoned woks that are at par with traditional Chinese woks, this black steel wok is a must-have! The round-bottomed skillet is professional-grade, heavy-duty and works great on open-fire and gas. The seasoned carbon steel ensures that the flavours of the food stay intact and fresh. The wooden handle is welded directly into the pan for optimum handling of the utensil and easy maneuvering.

Specifications:

  • Size: 14 inch
  • Item weight: 3.88 pounds

Pros:

  • Excellent for professionals.
  • Greater longevity and durability.

Cons:

  • Unsuitable for beginners.
  • Slightly high maintenance.
Check Latest price on Amazon

8. Mamafong Flat-Bottomed Carbon-Steel Wok

Best Mamafong Flat-Bottomed Carbon-Steel Wok Review
Buy from Amazon

Hand-hammered by craftsmen in China, this flat-bottomed carbon-steel wok is the ultimate Asian wok you need to cook all your Asian dishes. Conducive for gas and electric kitchen tops, the carbon steel pan has the superior heating capability and evenly sears, fries and heats veggies and all kinds of meat with ease. To manage the heavy body of the carbon steel pan, the handle is fastened to the wood directly with tightly fitted screws. Additionally, the flat bottom ensures that the contents of the pan do not spill or slip out during cooking.

Specifications:

  • Size: 14 inch
  • Item weight: 3.36 pounds

Pros:

  • Suitable for professional and residential cooking.
  • Designed by craftsmen using special techniques.

Cons:

  • Heavy gauge body.
  • Difficult to maneuver for beginners.
Check Latest price on Amazon

9. De Buyer Mineral B Round Country Chef Carbon Steel Pan

Best 9. De Buyer Mineral B Round Country Chef Carbon Steel Pan Review
Buy from Amazon

Anyone who loves cooking swears by De Buyer cookware. The utensils are top-grade and enhances the flavour of your food. This round country chef pan is perfect for searing meat and frying veggies, the depth of the skillet ensures that the oil does not spill out. It is well-known that De Buyers coats it’s utensils with beeswax to protect them from oxidation, so this pan also comes pre-seasoned which makes it super easy to sear or cook food. This is the best carbon steel pan there is and although it is not dishwasher safe, it can easily be washed with hot water and wiped with a cloth before storage.

Specifications:

  • Size: 9.5 inch
  • Item weight: 4.27 pounds

Pros:

  • Maintenance is the same as cast-iron.
  • Easy to use and store.

Cons:

  • Slightly high maintenance.
  • Heavy-weighted.
Check Latest price on Amazon

10. KYTD Flat-Bottomed Carbon-Steel Wok Pan

Best KYTD Flat-Bottomed Carbon Steel Wok Pan Reviewed
Buy from Amazon

Light-weight wok pans are not a thing of the future anymore, they are here and function at power with the heavy-duty gauge works! This 12.5-inch pan is toxic-free, non-stick, hand-hammered to perfection using traditional Chinese methods and is perfect for a large family. Suitable for induction, electric and gas stoves alike this pan has a detachable vintage bakelite handle that is ergonomically designed for heating, searing, boiling and all kinds of cooking requirements. To add an element of surprise the non-stick carbon-steel skillet also comes with a wooden lid and spatula.

Specifications:

  • Size: 12.5 inch
  • Item weight: 5.64 pounds

Pros:

  • The pricing is affordable.
  • Non-stick and easy to use.

Cons:

  • May potentially rust if not maintained well.
  • Heavy-weighted.
Check Latest price on Amazon

11. BK Nature Carbon Frying Pan

Best BK Nature Carbon Frying Pan Review
Buy from Amazon

Coming from the Dutch brand BK, which gave the world Dutch ovens and revolutionized the cookware industry, this nature carbon frying pan is a classic kitchen tool. Coated with a non-stick patina layer the light-weight skillet works on all heating sources and hence is suitable for all kinds of kitchen tops. The beechwood handle is designed to sear, fry and boil food items to perfection and for easy maneuvering of the pan. The maintenance and cleaning of the carbon steel pan are absolutely easy and hassle-free.

Specifications:

  • Size: 12. inch
  • Item weight: 3.09 pounds

Pros:

  • Extremely light but sturdy and durable.
  • Non-stick and easy to clean.

Cons:

  • Material is thin.
  • May rust if not well-maintained.
Check Latest price on Amazon

How to Choose The Best Carbon Steel Skillet?

Although carbon steel pans are fairly easy to manage, there are certain ways to choose the best one for you.

Shape and Size
Carbon steel pans come in multiple shapes, ranging from extremely flat to curved to curved with a flat bottom (the ones used for woks!) and so on. You need to know your purpose well before making a purchase. For example, if you were to sear or fry meat and regular veggies you could go in for a flat bottomed medium-sized pan. However, for Asian cooking wok style, curve-bottom pans are apt.

Seasoning
Carbon pans need to be seasoned prior to usage. Most pans today come pre-seasoned, however, after repeated usage these too need seasoning. Hence, it is better to use pans that can be seasoned easily.

Maintenance
Although carbon-steel pans are easier to maintain compared to cast-iron, they still need to be cared for. You need to wash it with a little hot water and very mild soap before cleaning and storing it. If you think you have that kind of patience and interest then carbon-steel is the way to go!

Frequently Asked Questions About Best The Carbon Steel Skillets:

Can Carbon Steel Skillet Be Used On A Glass Stove Top?

Definitely! Carbon steel can be used for glass stoves as well as for electric, gas and induction. Just like iron-cast skillets and other non-stick pans, carbon-steel is easy on maintenance and usage.

Conclusion

Carbon steel pans are an absolute bliss to use when it comes to searing and frying cooking items. On most occasions, it is used in place of iron-cast pans, as it is lighter and more versatile compared to iron-cast. Recommended for professional and residential cooking alike, carbon-steel evenly heats up, is durable and budget-friendly. Since carbon-steel pans get better with every seasoning, they often serve as family heirlooms and are passed on from one generation to the other.

Interesting Articles for You:

  • Best Pizza pans
  • Best Grill Pans
  • Best Saute Pans
  • Best Pans To Cook Eggs
  • Best Pans To Cook Steak

Filed Under: Cooking

You May Also Like

Best Broiler Pans Reviewed
Top 14 Best Broiler Pans to Buy In 2022 with Buying Guide
Best Tamagoyaki Pans Reviewed
11 Best Tamagoyaki Pans of 2022 Reviewed
Best Saute Pans Reviews
15 Best Saute Pans for Searing & Braising in 2022

About Medha

Hi there! I am Medha
I am a creative writer, reader, a poet, a travel, a fitness enthusiast and a big time foodie (with a sweet tooth, if you must!)
I have been a writer for over 5 years and it brings me so much joy to observe and pen down my feelings and share the same with friends and family. GuideYouBest is my personal favorite because it seeks to resolve your problems by providing viable solutions. I hope we can help you find what you seek and that we can GuideYouBest.

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Skillet Vs. Frying Pan: What is the difference between them?
  • Top 14 Best Broiler Pans to Buy In 2022 with Buying Guide
  • The 15 Best Pans for Brownies to Buy in 2022
  • 11 Best Tamagoyaki Pans of 2022 Reviewed
  • 11 Best Donut pans for Baking Home Treats in 2022

Footer

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

About GuideYouBest

GuideYouBest reviews a variety of products and displays top picks in each category.

  • Kitchenware
  • Tips
  • Privacy Policy for GuideYouBest
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Cookie Policy
  • Partnerships & Advertising
  • Contact Us

Copyright © Guideyoubest 2021